Best restaurants and fine dining in Winter Haven, Florida

Winter Haven has a variety of restaurants and eateries, from casual to gourmet, offering diverse food experiences. 

Arabella’s Italian Ristorante reigns as a top choice for upscale dining, blending Old World charm with modern elegance. This family-owned gem specializes in authentic Italian cuisine, from hand-rolled pastas like lobster ravioli to crispy wood-fired pizzas. Diners praise its intimate, candlelit atmosphere, curated wine list, and impeccable service, earning it a 4.8-star rating for romantic evenings or special celebrations.  

Harry’s Old Place is a beloved lakeside institution, serving fresh Gulf and Atlantic seafood since 1980. Locals flock here for the iconic “Harry in a Bag” grouper—lightly fried and topped with Ritz crackers, pecans, and lemon butter—paired with panoramic waterfront views. The rustic, laid-back vibe and hearty portions (think coconut shrimp and clam chowder) make it a quintessential Florida experience, perfect for families or sunset dinners on the dock. 

 For a modern twist on farm-to-table dining, Nutwood shines with its inventive, seasonal menu. Dishes like duck confit with cherry gastrique and truffle-infused risotto highlight locally sourced ingredients, while the sleek, minimalist decor and craft cocktail program create a refined yet welcoming atmosphere. With rave reviews for its creative flair and attentive staff, Nutwood has quickly become a destination for foodies seeking bold flavors and culinary artistry.  

Together, these restaurants capture Winter Haven’s diverse culinary spirit—from lakeside comfort to Italian tradition and contemporary innovation—ensuring unforgettable dining experiences.